Social Media Activism: The Physical and Virtual World in Twitter, Portland, and Beyond
I conducted my interview practicum with my friend from the MENA region about how he uses social media, and the use of social media for politics around him. As I set off to expand on this interview, and began combing Twitter for political posts from various countries in the Arab World, I was constantly confronted with the unrest and activism in the US. After spending a few hours in the last two days scrolling through pages and pages of content from protesters in Portland, and being presented with a considerably lower proportion of political activity on Arabic Twitter, I decided to shift my regional focus back home for this class’s final project. At first I thought perhaps it might be interesting to compare the use of social media in countries like Lebanon with its use in the US, but I found myself not only confronted with an unclear vision of what social media activism looks like in Lebanon from my observations, but also a daunting translation project of videos, screenshots, and other online media for only one week.
My original interview was broad and lacked any participant observation as backup to guide my questions. Having now done a few hours of participant observation, I feel more prepared to approach this ethnographic study with a more focused research question. As I scrolled, I noticed an interesting phenomenon: different people posting about the same video or tweet would have radically different reactions to the same piece of content. This makes me think of the various audiences that each poster is aiming to read their post, and the separations between these audiences, and their overlaps. What does the political geography of social media look like? Are there tone/audience differences between platforms? It’s obvious how the physical world affects this virtual one, but how does this virtual one affect the real world?
ِAn interesting approach to carrying out this research more in-depth would be to identify pieces of popular political content, and find various posts and reactions to them on a multitude of internet platforms, like Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Reddit, YouTube comments, and more.
For a multimedia platform, I found the various types of text, image, video, and gif interfaces especially compelling, and something that would be well-suited for this type of project. By centering an approach on the media of the posts themselves, the research would lend itself well to being conveyed via a multimedia presentation.
For an example I’ve included two posts of different people reacting to the same video of protesters at the Columbus statue in Grant Park.
6 Comments Already
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Interested to see more, Seth! I can imagine the news clip playing with different twitter responses fading in and out…. curious to see how you choose to bring this all together!
This is a really interesting idea! I’m interested in the way that you plan on presenting this data. I think that utilizing the media as a center for your project is definitely the way to go. I think that there are a lot of interesting ways to portray these images as multiplicities, filled with all sorts of interpretations and voices interacting with one another.
This is a really interesting topic! Most news companies post the same articles/multimedia content on various social media platforms, so that may be one way to compare the responses across platforms.
Very cool topic and also very pertinent! If you wanted to go outside of the realm of the content available to you on Twitter, Facebook, etc., you could potentially do interviews with friends or family members about their use of social media and how they engage with politics on social media. That could provide audio to go with screenshots and gifs you find in your search.
I admire your honest reflection of your research process! I also think the questions you ask at the second paragraph are super important and interesting. I’ve been thinking about these same issues myself, and it’s crazy (even humorous if you forget it’s reality) how two different sources will portray the same event under drastic perspectives. It’s also made me think about the power of framing and especially how it works for headlines. I’ve observed that many people will only consume headlines without actually opening articles and reading the information. In that way, media platforms capitalize on their outrage. I wonder if this will come up in your own research, in which case I’d be really excited to hear what you find. Regardless tho, I’m interested where your project goes!
This is such a cool project and also feels very relevant right now. I agree with Ife that some interviews may be a good addition to the project if you have the time, especially since it’s on stuff in the news that kind of bridges the virtual/physical spaces