Better to Rule in Hell: A Comparison of Satan in Paradise Lost and the Old English Genesis

Why does Satan choose to rebel against God?  While Satan is not mentioned in the Book of Genesis, he is featured prominently in its Old English counterpart.  The story of Satan’s rebellion and fall provided by Old Testament Narratives (OTL) is remarkably similar to that which appears in Milton’s Paradise Lost.  Satan conspires to reign over Heaven, he and his angelic host are overthrown, their luminous forms are twisted into devils, and the devils are cast down into Hell.  After making a grand speech to his followers, Satan then hatches a scheme of revenge to thwart God by corrupting man, who God creates as a replacement for the fallen angels. 

Although the two narratives share these same broad strokes, there are some distinctions in the finer details.  According to Genesis A, Satan’s original sin was his desire to “partition” Heaven, setting aside for himself and his followers “a home and a throne in the northern part of the kingdom of heaven” (5).  God ironically fulfills this secessionist wish by “form[ing] a home in banishment for that traitor [in] the howls of hell” (5).  Thus Satan, who arrogantly hoped to reign over a swathe of Heaven, instead becomes the king of Hell.  This version of events differs somewhat from Milton’s, in which Satan aspires to supplant God as sole ruler over all of Heaven, not just its northern reaches.  Interestingly, though, Milton’s Satan is also said to “possess / The Quarters of the North” of Heaven (5.686), though this may be a coincidence. 

In Milton’s version of events, Satan first strays from God out of jealousy of Christ the Son, who replaces him as God’s right hand and favored child (5.659-69); this adds a shade of sibling rivalry to Satan’s grievances.  What irks Satan most, however, is not that he is less favored in God’s eyes than the Son but that he ranks lower in the celestial hierarchy.  Satan complains more than once about the Son’s “newness,” resenting him for having skipped to the front of the line: “The great MESSIAH, and his new commands…speedily through all the Hierarchies / Intends to pass triumphant” (5.688-90).  Both Satans despise servitude; while Milton’s Satan may have tolerated being God’s inferior, he cannot countenance being third in line.  As Satan famously declares in Paradise Lost: “Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven” (1.263). 

In both narratives, Satan’s ambition to rule proves his undoing: “He could not find it in his mind that he would serve God, the prince, in obedience…He planned how he would create a stronger throne for himself” (OTN 21-23).  Unlike in Paradise Lost, where Satan wages a full-scale rebellion against God, Satan in the Old English Genesis never seems to get beyond mere planning.  God, the supreme witness, hears of his “great boast” (5), punishing him and his followers for their treasonous intent.  This is why Satan complains that God “could not accuse us of any sin, that we carried out any harm in [heaven]” (31), since, at the time of his banishment, he had not yet put word into action. 

Satan also claims that God can read his mind, and that God had him bound in chains in order to prevent him from meddling with Adam (31).  Satan solves this problem by sending an intermediary to act in his stead (33), apparently overlooking the fact that if God can read his mind, he will no doubt have foreseen this course of action.  In Paradise Lost, the devils also contemplate the prospect of God’s omniscience and the problem that it poses for their schemes of revenge.  Belial, in his speech to the infernal parliament, advises giving up the struggle against God, since, “who [can] deceive his mind, whose eye / Views all things at one view? he from heaven’s highth / All these our motions vain, sees and derides” (2.189-91).  The other devils, though, ignore his correct reasoning, just as Satan in the OTN fails to appreciate the implications of God’s mind-reading abilities.  After all, how can anyone aspire to defeat a foe who is omniscient and omnipotent? 

In both versions, Satan ultimately does resolve not to combat God directly but rather to injure him by damning humanity.  One interesting point of similarity between the two is God’s motivation for creating man.  In the OTN, God creates humanity to fill the vacant thrones of heaven, “settl[ing] with a better troop the great creations and the native-seats after that, the bright radiant thrones, those which the boastful destroyers had given up, high in the heavens” (9).  Likewise, in Paradise Lost, God announces to his loyal angels that he will create mankind in order to deny Satan the satisfaction of having depopulated heaven: “But lest his heart exalt him in [having] dispeopled Heav’n…I can repair / That detriment…and in a moment will create…out of one man a race / Of men innumerable” (7.150-56).  Thus, by Milton’s account, mankind was created literally to spite the devil.    

111 thoughts on “Better to Rule in Hell: A Comparison of Satan in Paradise Lost and the Old English Genesis

  1. In this sexual taboo, the “older” spouse might be witnessed as dominant or knowledgeable, even though the “younger” associate may well be
    perceived as submissive. There, massage may possibly have performed
    a insignificant nearby job as a immediate import from countries of origin.
    However, for good reasons that have previously been mentioned, a woman who is strongly sexed,
    and of a pronounced amorous mother nature, can manage even wonderful
    excess of sexual intercourse training with no struggling these kinds of sick outcomes
    as would befall a gentleman who should so indulge.
    1919 Produced by the American Social Hygiene Association, targets younger
    females with warnings about premarital sexual intercourse and venereal disorder.
    This 7 days I arrived across an article titled “Why really do not video games take sexual intercourse seriously? I’m not wholly guaranteed that this is the similar firm – the simple fact that Getting Out Our Dreams II, LLC is referenced in that report as a variation on the name of his before label, Getting Out Our Dreams would make me experience like they could not be the similar point. “The better the depth of the story,
    the much better and more quickly the toy’s
    reaction will be,” the company promises. If girls do not want to breastfeed, the mammary glands will end manufacturing milk after 1-2 weeks of not remaining suckled or pumped.

  2. III “Cruel”-Excessive Delays The problems of reliability
    and unfairness nearly inevi­ tably result in a 3rd independent constitutional drawback: excessively lengthy periods of time that people typically spend on dying row, alive but beneath
    sentence of demise. It was the primary and solely time he’d ever
    been arrested. In Santiago, attributable to technical points caused by heavy rain, the complete first
    act was cut and the live performance began with “Express Yourself”.
    Over 300 ensembles were used over the course of your complete film.

    In 1999, the singer was chosen to contribute a
    single on the soundtrack for Myers’ second film about the spy character Austin Powers, titled Austin Powers:
    The Spy Who Shagged Me. On the second Madison Square
    Garden present, Psy joined Madonna onstage for a mashup performance of “Gangnam Style”,
    “Give It 2 Me” and “Music”. During the second live performance in Mexico City,
    Madonna sang “Spanish Lesson”. This live performance was
    declared by Madonna as a “Concert for Peace”,
    inviting several peace organizations to
    honor and acknowledge people seeking peace within the Middle East.

  3. She had inner sensors in order that when you touched her
    hand she would say, “I love holding fingers with you” when in “Frigid Farrah”
    mode, or “I know a spot you may put that hand” when in “Wild Wendy” mode.
    But then this lady walked in , me and Jean both eliminated our hands from Big
    Woman and walked out of the restroom. For as little as a
    dime, readers might enter into an action-packed adventure wherein the
    heroes slugged their means out of tight spots in varied exotic corners
    of an improbable world. Steeped in the politics of the left-leaning,
    working-class Depression milieu from which Superman emerged, the man of steel’s first appearance exhibits him foiling a lynching, roughing up conflict profiteers, breaking a wrongly convicted assassin out
    of loss of life row, and beating his ideals into this home
    abuser. They must be taught that when going right into a physique of water, they should go in ft first the primary time
    to check the depth. That same year, to commemorate
    Tharpe’s first anniversary of being a homeowner
    in Richmond, Virginia, Tharpe placed on a live performance at what’s now the Altria Theater.
    Estyn stated they felt “only some teachers” would do something about it if they heard homophobic slurs getting used in opposition to them.

  4. For example, on the scales measured by the massive Five
    persona traits women consistently report larger neuroticism, agreeableness, warmth
    and openness to emotions, and males often report larger assertiveness and openness to concepts.
    When pursuits had been classified by RIASEC type Holland Codes (Realistic, Investigative,
    Artistic, Social, Enterprising, Conventional), males had been found
    to choose working with things, whereas girls most popular working with people.

    Analysis of the research has discovered a lack of
    credibility when relying on published research about cognition as a result of most contain findings of cognitive differences between the males
    and females, but they overlook those that don’t show any variations, creating a pool of biased information. In maze and path
    completion tasks, males be taught the objective route in fewer trials than females,
    but females remember extra of the landmarks introduced. Although research on intercourse variations in aggression show that males are
    generally more prone to show aggression than females, how a
    lot of this is due to social elements and gender expectations
    is unclear. A highschool version known as “Company Program” focuses extra
    in-depth on entrepreneurship and enterprise by bringing in volunteer consultants from the local business group.

  5. These are my reasons for concluding that this excess
    over men, as a criminal towards individuals, inside these limits,
    is the result of the extra energetic development of the emotions in girls.
    If that is any explanation, it follows that one sex must so vastly exceed the opposite in the matter of intoxication and disorderly conduct, as it is termed by the police courts,
    as not only to incorporate the ratio between the sexes for crimes
    mentioned, but also to incorporate the probabilities of no
    such result following, as but a small share of debauches and brawls leads to both
    homicide or assassination. Esther startled the prison officials
    one morning, by charging the night-watch-a most estimable
    young man-with visiting her cell at night time. The following history of a false
    accusation reveals the defective management
    over the feelings and the perversion of the sexual emotions which coexist with the hysterical tendency:
    Esther was a young convict, about twenty years previous, dedicated for a time period of
    years to the Onondaga penitentiary for a second offense of stealing.
    A false accusation of this nature isn’t a really rare one for women to make,
    and it is normally accompanied by two noteworthy
    circumstances-the girl is usually very younger, and the man in some way almost
    unattainable by the accuser.

  6. Cato the Younger, who offered himself as a paragon modeled immediately after his moral namesake, authorized his expecting
    wife Marcia to divorce him and marry Hortensius, declining to give his younger daughter
    to the 60-calendar year-outdated orator in its place.
    The censors of 307 BCE as a result expelled him from the Senate for moral turpitude.
    By the 1st century CE, most elite gals prevented breast-feeding their infants on their own and
    thus employed soaked-nurses. Large households have been not the
    norm amongst the elite even by the Late Republic the household
    of Clodius Pulcher, who experienced at least three sisters and two brothers, was considered abnormal.
    Domestic abuse enters the historical report predominantly when it requires the egregious excesses of the elite.
    Inscriptions report her generosity in funding the renovation of the Sardis gymnasium.
    Women also joined in funding community operates, as is commonly documented by inscriptions during
    the Imperial period. The period may possibly have authorized for pregnancy: if a lady had become
    expecting just prior to her husband’s dying, the period of 10 months ensured that no query
    of paternity — which could have an affect on the kid’s social standing and inheritance — arose.
    While no official waiting time period was dictated
    for a widower, it was customary for a lady to stay in mourning for ten months prior to remarrying.

  7. On May 31, 2020, Super Junior executed a exclusive
    on the internet dwell concert dubbed Beyond
    the Super Show, which was broadcast via Naver’s V Live application as section of a joint job in between SM and Naver
    termed Beyond Live. Super Show 8″ Concert In Kuala Lumpur Postponed”.
    Beyond the Super Show showcased the same 8-member lineup as Super Show 8:
    Infinite Time and showcased MAX from TVXQ as a special webcam guest.
    The wives who had been reliant on their husband would decide that they hate him and will cheat on him but will continue
    to be with him, but spend as minimal time as attainable with
    him. All that return with Jesus will also reign and rule.
    It is far more probable that you will identify the individual
    you need if there are hundreds of live chatters readily available at all situations.

    It is identical to Omegle in that there are random reside movie chats and text chat rooms accessible, but iMeetzu goes over and
    previously mentioned that. One day, you go purchasing for
    yoga pants, and the upcoming working day you are standing thoroughly bare in entrance of the digicam.
    Beyond Live concerts highlighted interactive fanlight sequences,
    augmented phase graphics, and multi-cam aid for fans who wished
    to target on one particular precise member.

  8. As pointed out in my 31/7 entry, I also dislike
    that it utilizes a individual database somewhat than keep entries
    in simply-obtainable flat .txt documents. I dislike the experience that I am significantly leasing my OS somewhat than proudly owning it – that it is not beneath my whole manage.
    The related departments beneath the State Council shall, in compliance with their outlined obligations and in accordance with law,
    exercise command around the import and export of narcotic and psychotropic substances and the chemical components that can conveniently be transformed into narcotic
    medicines. Some ladies might truly feel vulnerable in this position, as it needs and indicates a
    stage of have faith in and a surrender of handle by the getting to the energetic
    companion. Non-fictional will work that portray intercourse or sexual themes may incorporate fictional elements.
    Was I more of a intercourse addict or a drug addict?

    “We know that autonomous motor vehicles can make smarter use of present highway networks so they can go around additional freely and efficiently …

  9. If some one wants to be updated with most up-to-date technologies after that he
    must be pay a visit this site and be up to date
    every day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *